Rosh Hashanah 5787: Do Jews Have a Future in America?

Rabbi Dan Dorsch, Congregation Etz Chaim, Marietta, Georgia

This summer at Camp Ramah, one of the older Gesher campers walked up to me and asked, “Rabbi…do you work as a politics rabbi?”

I looked at him.  “A what?”  “A politics rabbi.”  Then it hit me.  He didn’t mean politics…He meant pulpit.

I laughed. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized his mistake wasn’t entirely accidental.

Because over the past year, it has sometimes felt as though people expect those two things to be one and the same.  Especially when it comes to this question that I’ve been asked more than any other this year that isn’t really a political question at all.  It’s a profoundly Jewish one.

People have leaned over after services, caught me in the hallway, lowered their voices just enough so no one else could hear, and asked: “Rabbi…do you really think Jews have a future in this country?”

Friends, this was supposed to be a celebratory year. America is marking its 250th birthday. And yet, if we’re being honest, it hasn’t always felt much like a celebration. Not for Jews anyway.

As Jews we’re proud, but concerned.  Maybe hopeful, but uneasy.  Grateful for the extraordinary blessings this country has given us, yet increasingly anxious about what the future may hold.

The question “Do Jews have a future in this country?”, sounds profoundly modern.  Yet for Jews, it is as old as the diaspora itself.  It’s the same question our ancestors whispered in Babylonia…in Russia…in Iran…in countless lands where we wondered whether our best days were behind us or in front of us.  The countries change.  The centuries change.  But the question never really does.

We carry our history in our bones.  We know what it means to wonder whether the shelter above our heads is as sturdy as it once was.  For Jews, 250 years is barely a paragraph in our story.

There is only one problem.  When Jews gather together, we never answer questions with one voice.

If I were to ask everyone in this room whether Jews have a future in America, I suspect I would hear at least three different answers…along with three different opinions about how to change the light bulb.

Because Jews always have one voice that worries.  Another that hopes.  And a third that calls us back to faith.

This morning, I want us to listen to all three.  Because I believe each of those voices has something important to teach us, not only about who we are right now at America at 250, but what it has always meant to live as a Jew in the Diaspora.

Let’s begin with the voice that worries.  Because in a room full of Jews, I don’t want to pretend that voice isn’t familiar to almost all of us.

The Worried among us aren’t imagining that something feels different in America right now.  You feel it. So do I.  Think back ten, twenty years.  Political historian Yoni Appelbaum writes that America is becoming defined less by consensus than by conflict.  For Americans that might simply be a political observation.  But for Jews it awakens memory.  Because we have been there before.

There was a rabbi in 1930s Berlin who understood what it meant when a society began to change around him. His name was Joachim Prinz.

Many Americans know Rabbi Prinz because he marched beside Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. at the March on Washington.  But in 1930s Berlin, Prinz saw something many German Jews would not or could not see. He recognized that the ground beneath their feet was shifting. The shelter that had protected German Jewish life for generations was becoming increasingly unstable.  So he did what courageous rabbis hope they have the strength to do. Week after week, he denounced the Nazi regime from his pulpit. He was arrested by the Gestapo. And eventually he was told that if he wished to live, he had to leave Germany.

On his final Shabbat, he stood before a sanctuary filled with Jews who desperately wanted reassurance.  They wanted their rabbi to tell them not to worry.

Instead, he told 3,500 Jews to look at the clock.  The hour, he said, was midnight for the Jews of Germany.  It was time to pack up and go.  Remove the mezuzot.  Take the Torah scrolls out of the ark.  Close the shul.  And to flee Germany for the sake of their children.

The Jews of Germany did not listen.  We know what happened.

We are not living at midnight.  I am not going to give that sermon to you today.  But that does not mean that, like many of you who worry, I haven’t occasionally found myself looking at the clock.  Ticking.  Perhaps a warning tock.

American philosopher Richard Weaver wrote that the trouble with every generation is that it fails “to read the minutes of the last meeting.”  Twenty-five years after the tragic events of 9/11, it’s dumbfounding how many young Americans upvoting Hamas seem to have this problem.  But as Jews, as the people who worry, it seems, we are cursed, to never have that problem.  We carry the pogroms.  We carry expulsions.  We carry the Shoah.  We move into new homes.  We meet the neighbors.  And what’s the first thing we wonder: Are these the kinds of people who would hide us, or the ones who would keep silent?

Dara Horn writes that in 1941, ⅓ of the businesses in downtown Baghdad were owned by Jews.  In 1950, Iraq’s government stripped 120,000 Jews of their citizenship, seized their property, and told them to leave.  Forget 250…that was after 2500 years of living there. And if it weren’t for Israel, they would’ve had nowhere to go.

That is why we hear today’s rhetoric in America differently.  We hear danger on campuses and in the coarsening of political discourse.  We hear danger when antisemitism is excused and normalized.  We carry centuries of hard-earned memory, even when others forget.  That is why Jews worry.  Not because we are paranoid.  It’s because this voice tells us we always have to remember to always look at the clock.

But Jewish life has never been sustained by voices of worry alone.  Because if worry teaches us to notice the bluster in the wind, hope teaches us why our shelter may still yet hold.

There are people here in this room who hope.  Sometimes, we hope at the same time as we worry.  The hopeful voice is not naïve.  It does not pretend antisemitism doesn’t exist.  It does not deny the uncertainty.  It simply insists that gratitude is every bit as Jewish as caution.  It is a voice that reminds us that when we think about the history of America, we cannot forget about the promise made to a man named Jonas Phillips.

Phillips was a Jew. He was one of the founders of Mikveh Israel in Philadelphia who three weeks after the Declaration of Independence was signed was gifted one of its first copies.

Imagine that moment.  For the first time in nearly two thousand years.  There it was. Phillips could see the future: the astonishing possibility that he had finally found a place where he could dig roots and build a home.  A shelter unlike any other Jews had ever known before.  America was unique.  A precious land.  Singular in its promise.  Singular in its majesty.  Singular in its tolerance.

He sat down and wrote a letter in Yiddish to a friend in Amsterdam on the back of his copy of the Declaration of Independence.  The letter never arrived.  A British warship intercepted it.  It thought the Yiddish was a secret military code.  In a way, they were right.  It was a coded message of hope.

Jonas Phillips would live to see that his hopes in America were not misplaced.  His grandson, Uriah Phillips Levy became the first Jewish Commodore in the United States Navy.

He would fight antisemitism all the way to the top.  But despite that, Uriah would persevere.  Because he understood that the story of Jews in America has never been utopia.  Our story is about overcoming adversity.  That’s the hope.  And friends, I’d like to suggest that even now, even though times seem to be challenging, we cannot lose hope in our same shared perseverance, recognizing that we are living in one of the most extraordinary times to be a Jew in the history of the world.  We can’t forget that.

Rabbi David Wolpe imagines himself complaining to his great-grandfather about today.  “Zaida, it’s terrible. Look at all the antisemitism at Harvard.”  His great-grandfather looks puzzled.  “Wait…there are Jews at Harvard?”  “Yes. But look at all the anti-Israel sentiment.”  “Wait…there’s an Israel?”  “Yes. But people are talking about reducing some of the billions of dollars America sends to support it.”  “America gives billions of dollars to a Jewish state?”  Suddenly the perspective changes.

Never forget that in 2021, for the first time in World Series history, a Jewish batter hit the ball off a Jewish pitcher and it was caught by a Jewish outfielder.  Fried to Bregman to Pederson.  Dayeinu.

Never forget this summer, I stood in a grocery store holding what may be one of the greatest achievements of American civilization.  Kansas City Pulled Pork Pringles.  Kosher dairy.  Certified by the Orthodox Union.  Don’t ask me what was in them.  Don’t ask me how many years they took off my life.  I don’t want to know.

All I know is that there is probably no other country in the world where kosher Kansas City Pulled Pork potato chips could possibly exist.  It was, if only for one glorious bite, a taste of the World to Come.  Kosher trief.  Nes Gadol Haya Po (A Great Miracle Happened Here).

Now, that sounds silly.  But I know that you understand that beneath the humor is something profound.  Our ancestors thousands of years ago dreamed about surviving.  I get to debate with my colleagues which flavor of Pringles we like best.  We are not living in normal times.  It is a mechayeh.  It is a marvel: a marvel that could only take place in America.

It is the hopeful voice that does not deny today’s challenges.  It is the hopeful voice that simply refuses to let today’s headlines blind us to two and a half centuries of the unimaginable and the glorious.

And so who is right?  Which is it?  The Worried?  Or the Hopeful?

The truth is, after listening to both voices, I find myself unable to dismiss either one.  Neither can you.

The Worried are right that history can turn.  Jews ignore the lessons of history at their peril.  But the Hopeful are right too.  America has been an extraordinary blessing.   We live in a country that has offered Jews freedoms, opportunities, dignity, and possibility unlike any we have known in history.

So which voice should we heed?  Which way do we change the lightbulb?

For me, here, today, on Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish answer has never been found in choosing between worry and hope.  The Jewish answer is to be found in a third voice: the voice of faith.

Because faith asks a different question altogether.  Not whether a society is perfect.  Or whether it is permanent.  But whether we understand our place within it.

Today as America celebrates 250 years, as Jews, we celebrate 5,787 years since the creation of the world.  As Jews, we will say Hayom harat olam, Today the world is born.

Our story is older than America.  We have prayed beneath kings, czars, and presidents. We have seen kingdoms rise and fall. We have watched nations that seemed permanent disappear into history.

It’s true.  Some people speak as though America is becoming Egypt.  A place from which Jews must flee.  Others speak as though America is the Promised Land.  The final destination of our story.

But today, on Rosh Hashanah, and during this holiday season, Judaism asks us to see something else.  I am going to ask the same of you too. America is neither Egypt nor the Promised Land.  It is a sukkah that carries us on our journey.

More than a century ago, Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch Masliansky, one of the great preachers of the immigrant generation, described America near its 150th birthday in words I have never forgotten.

He wrote in Yiddish:  “Of all the sukkot in all the lands of our Diaspora, the most beautiful and most kosher is the one we live in here, in the United States, over which flies the Stars and Stripes.”

My friends, during the penitential psalm we pray today we will ask God to shelter us in a Sukkah, and we will remember that for 250 years that shelter where our families have gathered has been America.  America is our home where our children laugh.  Where our values and yiddishkeit are cultivated.

Right now, I get it: America can feel like a shelter swaying in the wind.

But Sukkot reminds us that there is a Jewish answer to the infirmities and worries of life.  It is not despair.  It is not to take for granted.  Instead we have to build, strengthen, protect, and renew: Seeking out ways to make our country a place worthy of the opportunity God has given us.

Rabbi Joachim Prinz came to America not as a refugee, but to build this sukkah.  Jonas Phillips wasn’t simply content to enjoy America’s freedoms.  He built our future.  So did Rabbi Masliansky.  For generations, American Jews have not simply been content to live here.  We’ve carried the lumber and the greenery, our voices and our Torah from one sukkah to the next.  Our ancestors shaped this country.  And now, it’s our turn to do the same.

And so if that congregant were to ask me again, “Rabbi, do Jews have a future in America?”  I think I would answer differently.  I pray we do.   As we build the next generation of Jewish children in this country, I will do everything in my power to help ensure that we do.  And while God grants us the privilege of dwelling beneath this magnificent sukkah, I pray that we may always prove worthy of the privilege of dwelling inside of it.

Take it from this “pulpit rabbi.”  As America celebrates 250 years… as we begin another new year together…l pray that we have the wisdom to worry, the gratitude to hope, and the faith to honor this beautiful sukkah beneath the Stars and Stripes.  God bless America. May our brightest days be ahead of us.

L’shanah tovah.