United We Stand. Divided We Fall.
Erev Rosh HaShanah 5787 – September 11, 2026
Rabbi Jonathon Adler
Twenty-five years ago today was a bright, clear Tuesday in Manhattan. That morning, just before 9:00am, I got a phone call from my friend Shane. “Turn on the TV,” he said. “Any channel.” And I did, just in time to watch the second plane, United flight 175, hit the South Tower of the World Trade Center, downtown. I was in my apartment on the Upper East Side, four and a half miles away.
On Fifth Avenue later that day, I saw people–some covered in dust and ash–walking slowly uptown, in shock. On Wednesday, compelled by some unnamed power, I went downtown, to get as close as I could get to Ground Zero – which turned out to be Houston Street. My eyes watered at the plume of acrid smoke scarring the cloudless sky. Everyone was in a daze as the wind ruffled the “Missing” fliers that had been posted on a nearby wall.
Twenty-five years later, I remember it all, in details just as vivid as they were on those bright, awful days.
Soon, New York City began to empty out. By car, by train, and, a number of days later, by plane. Those of us who stayed in Manhattan experienced something new: we came together as a community. Neighbors began to talk, to check in with each other – in hallways, at corner stores, waiting for a bus.
A week later, the following Monday night, Rosh HaShanah 5762 began. Jewish communities came together in very different ways than they had the year before. We made teshuva not just individually, but collectively. Jews, along with all of the United States, embraced the nation’s new mantra, based on a quote from Patrick Henry: United We Stand.
We began to imagine a society built on that foundation of unity.
I don’t think any of us would have expected then that in 25 years, on Rosh Hashanah 5787, the world would look as it does now. Wars. Rampant antisemitism. Political divides wider than perhaps we’ve ever seen them. Polarization ending friendships and tearing families apart.
But the rift is broader than that. Beyond families around a table or a few friends out for drinks. Communities, news outlets, political parties, have all become antagonistic; our nation is straining under this weight.
Today, on Rosh Hashanah and on the 25th anniversary of 9/11, we’ve reached a time when we desperately need to remember the second half of Patrick Henry’s quote. “United we stand; divided we fall.”
Our sages teach us of the ramifications of division. In the Talmud, the rabbis ask each other what could the Jews have possibly done to bring about the destruction of the Temples in Jerusalem.
The Second Temple, they determine, was destroyed because of שנאת חינם. Baseless hatred. Even though the people engaged in Torah study, did mitzvot, and acts of kindness, there was enough hostility between various segments of the community to warrant that terrible event.
Divided, indeed, they fell.
And potent malice, on the part of extremists, is what led us to 9/11. But America stood united in the face of our enemies’ baseless hatred. We saw loathing, and collectively, we did not respond in kind.
In the early 1900s, Rav Kook, who would go on to become the Chief Rabbi of British Mandated Palestine, wrote about the destructive power of שנאת חינם, baseless hatred. He taught that just as there is deep-seated hatred in the world, so too, there is truth in the depth of great love. It is אהבת חינם, he said, baseless love, that will allow us to rebuild the world.
Today, אהבת חינם is how we can bring our country back together. It’s how we can build a nation based on reaching a common middle ground, rather than further separating ourselves based on opposing views. On a smaller scale, it’s how we can take care of each other.
How do we actually do this? How do we stand united in a time of so much division?
It’s not easy. But there are things each of us can do. Instead of saying that someone’s wrong, find common ground. Listen to people who are different and then push past those differences to ascertain how you’re alike. Discover what you both have in common and let that be a starting point. You may not agree with politics, but you both might share a love for a particular sport, favorite actor, or restaurant. That can be the first step to a special bond, and it’s one of just many ways we can each bring more baseless love into our personal relationships, and more broadly across our communities and our nation. Into a world that desperately needs more love.
As we enter into 5787, we have a remarkable opportunity as a community. Although so much of our Teshuva during the High Holy Days is personal, individual reflection, this year, אהבת חינם compels us to come together collectively, to work to bring our nation together. When we’re divided, we fall. But when we come together, when we unite – with love, with compassion, with teshuvah – we stand.
May we all be blessed with a new year of sweetness, of peace, and of standing together.
לשנה טובה תכתבו ותחתמו!