Is This The Hill I Want To Die On?
Rosh HaShanah 5787, Day Two. September 13, 2026
Rabbi Jonathon Adler
Recently, I had dinner with an old friend. He told me about some challenges he was having at his office. Mostly, they related to a colleague who always had fantastic ideas. Well, at least she thought her ideas were great. And undoubtedly they were, if only for the way that she felt things should be handled.
“In her mind, I’m sure things are lovely,” my friend said. “But they’re not. She pushes, and pushes, and nobody wants to use her plan. It works for her, but it’s not conducive to the way the rest of us do our jobs.”
She does this time and time again, he explained. My friend and his colleagues were getting sick of it, because the woman did not respond well when her co-workers chose to stick with the way they’d always done things. The old ways, which worked just fine. Yet with each idea that was shot down, she got more and more unpleasant. The atmosphere was charged.
But she couldn’t see that, not even when she was called to HR. The entire staff knew she was fighting a battle she would never win. But she picked that battle. She was adamant. And, you could say, she chose that hill to die on.
Ernest Hemingway first coined this idiom, dying on a hill, in For Whom The Bell Tolls, in a section about guerilla fighters meeting their doom during the Spanish Civil War. The author, who had been there as a war correspondent, noted that “many men throughout history have used a hill to die on.” He knew; he had seen their bodies.
By the Korean war, the idea of choice was added into the idiom which then moved into broader usage. And people began to ask:
“Is this the hill I want to die on?”
The earliest example of choosing to die on a hill is much earlier, though. It may well be from Bamidbar, the Book of Numbers.
Two years into the forty, frustrated with their lot, not accepting the thought of having to wander in the desert for 38 more years, a group of men decide to forge ahead into battle. This might seem very gutsy, but – spoiler alert – it’s quite foolish, which is why they’re called the Mapilim – the fallen ones, the ones who die on a hill.
Moses orders them to not embark on their mission. He admonishes them, telling them God is not with them and they will not survive this fool’s errand. Nevertheless, the men remain resolute, completely committed. They won’t let themselves walk away. By ignoring Moses’s warning, the men choose to die on that hill. Literally and figuratively. They’re wiped out by their foes.
They didn’t have to be. They could have chosen to turn away, not to die on that hill.
Each one of us makes multiple decisions every day. Some of them are major, and they affect the overall direction of our lives. Some are mundane, but even these can affect our relationships. Your spouse, for example, might not like the way you load the dishwasher. You can choose to die on that hill. You can pick a fight because you only like when the plates face one direction. Or you can decide that’s not a battle worth fighting. The dishes will still get clean. And your relationship won’t have to suffer.
When we’re faced with decisions, large or small, we must each ask ourselves, “is this the hill I want to die on?”
Each potential outcome comes with a cost. Yes, it might be minor. Perhaps we’ve wasted a few minutes of our time or turned the roll of toilet paper around. But it could be huge, even fatal. The question then becomes how important that cost is. It’s when we have to ask: Is this the hill?
The answer, more often than we expect it to be, is that this, whatever this is, doesn’t really matter, especially not in light of the consequences it may bring about.
The Talmud tells of a wealthy but nameless man who chooses the wrong hill while hosting an extravagant dinner party. He asks his servant to invite, among others, his friend Kamtza. The servant inadvertently invites Bar Kamtza, the host’s mortal enemy.
When Bar Kamtza shows up at the festivities, the host is irate and demands the man be removed at once. Bar Kamtza pleads with his host not to embarrass him by kicking him out. He offers to pay for his share, even the entire cost of the feast. But our host’s enmity means more to him. More than being in the same room as his enemy, more than taking his money – so he forces the man into the street.
Fuming at his humiliation, Bar Kamtza seeks immediate and devastating revenge. He goes straight to the Emperor and convinces him that the Jews are staging a mutiny. It’s the match that lights the fuse. The rabbis teach that this single act of hatred ignited the war resulting in the destruction of the Second Temple and the Jews’ centuries-long exile from our Holy Land. All because one wealthy man chose to embarrass his rival, rather than sit in a crowded room with him. Because the host chose the wrong hill to die on.
The wrong hill.
So what’s the right hill? When we stand at the bottom of a mountain, how do we know it’s the one we should be climbing?
That’s what Rosh Hashanah compels us to discern. Not to ask how to load the dishwasher or how to fall like the Mapilim.
The New Year is a time for each of us to ask: How can I stand up for what truly matters? When? Where?
To approach this, we can delve into our history. We can look to the heroes of the Israelites, of the Jewish people, throughout the years, such as two women whose choice of hill made a world of difference. Their names are Shifra and Puah, and they’re the Hebrew midwives in the Book of Exodus. Pharaoh orders them to kill every male baby born of a Hebrew woman.
Fortunately for us, these two fearless women led all the midwives to allow every single baby, boy or girl, to live. The midrash informs us that the women understand that each time they save the life of a baby boy, they’re putting their own at risk. They know that anyone caught disobeying Pharaoh is subject to capital punishment.
I can only imagine how terrified they must have been. How much devastation would Pharoah have wrought had he discovered what Shifra and Puah were up to?
The midwives know the risk. They also know that the collective fate of this nation is entirely in their hands at this point, so they choose. They each say to themselves, “This is where I draw the line. Here. This is the hill. Saving the Hebrews, granting our people a future, is more important than my own individual life. This is the hill I choose.”
The midwives chose, and the Hebrews lived. Just as the Jews lived when Esther made her choice to go to King Achashveros and reveal her identity, thus foiling Haman’s plan. Just as myriad resistance fighters risked death to save hundreds of thousands of Jews during the Holocaust. There are many more examples, but you probably want to get to lunch at a reasonable hour.
Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks, zt”l, taught that Judaism was – and remains – the world’s great religion of protest. Our heroes stand up. They understand which hills are worth dying on, and they commit.
The heroes of our past call on us to ask if the battles we’re choosing to fight are truly worth waging. Each of us has to ask, “Is this the hill I want to die on?” And we must each remember that it’s not only okay, but vital to know when to walk away. When to say, “Not THAT hill!”
Or when to know that hill is in your office.
My friend told me that since his colleague’s conversation with HR, she has changed; grown. Recently, the company rolled out some new software. Nobody was surprised when she made a suggestion that would enhance performance and allow the program to accommodate a larger set of cases than it was initially designed for. She was told, “No, the programmers aren’t interested in going that direction.”
The woman could have chosen the hill. She could have said, “No, you don’t understand. This is a big deal; doing this will make all our lives easier, and not doing it is short-sighted.”
But she didn’t. She said, “OK,” turned around, and didn’t look back at that hill. She had realized that what mattered most in that moment wasn’t having things her way. It wasn’t even making the best possible software. She was ensuring that she would be seen as a team player, as someone who supported the entire company instead of only caring about her own little corner of that world.
It takes a big person to do that.
I’m not sure if she knew it, but she was doing exactly what Rava, one of our most important Talmudic sages, taught in the 4th century CE.
כׇּל הַמַּעֲבִיר עַל מִדּוֹתָיו — מַעֲבִירִין לוֹ עַל כׇּל פְּשָׁעָיו
“Someone who lets go of their grievances,” someone who doesn’t always insist on being right, “has all their sins forgiven by the heavenly court.” In other words, actively choosing to turn away from the wrong hill is, in and of itself, doing right in the eyes of God.
Make no mistake: some hills are absolutely worth dying on. Just ask Shifra and Puah. What set them apart from Bar Kamtza’s nameless enemy, or from my friend’s colleague before her powerful moment of growth? They had a whole lot more than a grievance. Their hill held the future of an entire peoplehood.
Ask a hero of the Shoah, who chose the hill of one family or even one solitary person?
As we sit together in this sanctuary on Rosh Hashanah, as we welcome 5787, we must ask ourselves: what are the hills we each face at this moment?
And we must remember: the dishwasher’s a grievance. A software glitch is a grievance.
Other hills, though, are worth choosing to climb. Esther’s, for example. Or hills heroes have chosen throughout the years, not only in the Spanish Civil War or the Shoah.
Friends, we must remember that most of the hills we’re climbing right now, from the molehills to the mountains, are grievances. They’re not hills to die on. They’re hills to walk away from. Just like my friend’s colleague ultimately discovered.
The Days of Awe demand that we carefully consider every single hill before we begin the journey upwards. The teshuvah we make as we enter the New Year compels us to climb only when it truly matters. The hills of mitzvot. The mountains of our integrity, the peaks of our fundamental values as Jews and as humans. These are the heights worth scaling. These are the moments we each need to channel our own inner resistance fighter.
These are my prayers as we enter 5787. May God grant us the wisdom to recognize the hills worth climbing, the courage to commit to them, and the strength to reach their summits.
May 5787 be a year of blessing and sweetness. L’Shanah Tovah U’Metukah.