Rabbi Dan Dorsch, Congregation Etz Chaim, Marietta, Georgia
Tonight, I’ve spent a good deal of time saying confessionals and criticizing myself. Now, I am going to criticize a movie.
Actually, two movies.
One is the new Michael Jackson movie that has become the highest grossing biopic of all time, earning almost a billion dollars worldwide. The other is a budget comedy about a bar mitzvah from 2006 called Keeping Up with the Steins. In case you are curious, it earned approximately 995 million dollars…less. I watched it with my family as we prepared for Zev’s Bar Mitzvah (to which you are all invited).
The first follows the greatest entertainer of the twentieth century, who performed at Dodger Stadium. The other follows a neurotic Jewish family who planned to hold their son’s Bar Mitzvah party at Dodger Stadium.
Other than that, the films couldn’t be more different. And yet both movies wrestle with a question that I think is at the heart of Yom Kippur:
How much power should our past have over how we live life in the present?
Allow me to explain.
The Michael Jackson movie was a Thriller. Not Bad. I wanted to moonwalk on the airplane. But as I watched it, there was something about it that kept bothering me. Perhaps, even Dangerous about the film (I could “rock with you all night”).
What bothered me was that the movie spends a great deal of time explaining away his life choices rather than asking what responsibility he had for them.
The film’s directors hone in on his abusive father. The Pepsi Tour accident. The pressures of fame. The isolation that came with becoming one of the most famous people in the world. All terrible, horrific experiences. The film presents these experiences as central to understanding the person he became. The very public struggles he would endure later in life.
But you know, we all have trauma. We all have wounds. Experiences we had as children. All of us are shaped by unfair things we did not choose.
And yet after I finished watching the movie, I couldn’t help but think about the difference between saying:
“This happened to me, and it shaped me.” And saying: “This happened to me, this is who I’ve become, and don’t expect me to be any different.”
Because the first says that our experiences matter. They shape us. They leave wounds. But they do not have to define us.
The second says, “This is who I am now. I cannot change. And because of what happened to me, I have no responsibility to become anything different.”
And that distinction is at the heart of teshuvah.
Judaism absolutely acknowledges that our past shapes who we are. But Judaism refuses to let our past define us or have the final word.
Yom Kippur comes just ten days after the Torah tells us about the creation of humanity. And almost immediately in that story, we know humanity goes wrong.
Cain kills his brother Abel. And God comes looking for him.
What does Cain answer: “I do not know. Am I my brother’s keeper?”
The rabbis imagine Cain having an argument with God over the idea of personal accountability.
Cain tells God: You created me this way with a yetzer hara, an evil inclination. It’s your fault. Why are you blaming me for what I did?
From Cain to the interpretation presented by the movie Michael, we hear the same basic argument: My parents. My childhood. Out of my control. What happened to me has defined me. That’s just the way I am. I cannot be any different.
But Judaism doesn’t believe that. Yes, how we were born matters. What happens to us matters. But being shaped by our past is not the same thing as being dictated by it, nor does it remove our responsibility for where we go next.
And that brings me to the second movie.
Keeping Up with the Steins is a comedy about an absurdly extravagant Bar Mitzvah (this will not be the Dorsch bar mitzvah).
But underneath all the jokes about over-the-top parties and competitive parents is a story about a man who has allowed his childhood to determine his adulthood.
The main character, Adam, grew up with a father who abandoned his family.
He carries that hurt and resentment into his own marriage and his relationship with his son.
But eventually, his son gets tired of watching his father and grandfather fight. So, during the Bar Mitzvah party (I know I am spoiling the movie, but it’s from 2006, you’ve had twenty years to watch it), the boy walks into the swimming pool. His father and grandfather jump in after him.
And later, the boy says something that finally forces Adam to see what he has been doing.
“Are you going to stop fighting? Because the day I become a man, the two of you shouldn’t behave like children.” (mic drop)
It’s in that moment that Adam realizes that his father’s failures are going to be part of his story.
But they are not going to write the rest of it.
He can’t change what his father did. He can’t change his childhood. But he can decide what kind of father, what kind of husband, what kind of human being he will be.
And so in this very Jewish movie, Adam does teshuvah. He changes his behavior. And both Adam and his son learn something about what it means to become a Jewish adult.
It’s not having a perfect past. It’s choosing to take responsibility for the future.
Tonight, every person who walks into this sanctuary on Yom Kippur is carrying a story. Some of us carry parents who didn’t give us what we needed. Some of us carry painful relationships. Some carry disappointments with our children. Some carry grief. Feelings of betrayal. Shame. Secrets.
Tonight, I don’t want to ask you to pretend those things didn’t happen. They did. I also want to assure you that God knows those stories. And your pain. It’s not gone unheard or ignored.
But tonight, Yom Kippur is going to ask us to take one more step.
Not simply to ask: “What happened to me?” But: “What am I going to do now that it did?”
We tell ourselves that our distance from Judaism is someone else’s fault. We had a terrible religious school teacher. We’re never coming back. We tell ourselves that what happened in our marriage years ago still gets to determine our marriage today.
Maybe we really were hurt. Maybe someone really did fail us. Maybe someone treated us unfairly.
But the question is whether our past gets to determine what happens next. Whether we will let it have that power over us. Or learn from it and choose what we don’t want to repeat.
Earlier tonight, and all of tomorrow, we’re going to sing the Ashamnu. And there is something remarkable about the way that confession begins. Notice what it doesn’t say: “Our parents.” “Our spouse.” “My childhood.” It says: Ashamnu. Bagadnu. We have sinned. We strike our own chest.
Not because Judaism ignores our pain. Not because everyone else is innocent. But because teshuvah only can begin with personal accountability, when we recognize that something in this story belongs to us.
That is the promise of Yom Kippur. We cannot change yesterday. But we can and must refuse to let yesterday define what choices we make tomorrow.
Look, I love Michael Jackson’s music. It can be inspiring. Maybe that is why Michael Jackson’s greatest song is the one that brings us back to where we began.
For years, the world looked at Michael Jackson. His childhood. His family. His appearance. His struggles. His choices. And perhaps, as he was wrestling with some of his own struggles, he recorded a song that turned the question back on himself: Man in the Mirror.
That is exactly what Yom Kippur asks us to do. Not to look at our parents. Not to look at our spouses. Not to look at the people who hurt us. To look in the mirror. And to remind ourselves that if we “wanna make the world a better place, you have to look at yourself and make a change.”
The stories of Michael Jackson, Cain and Abel, and the Steins remind us that we cannot rewrite the opening chapters in the Book of our Life. But we do not have to allow those chapters to determine the ending.
Because even at this very moment on Yom Kippur, our story is still being written.
Our past may explain us. But it does not get to define us. That is the work of teshuvah that begins tonight.
Tonight, as we stand before God, the question is not simply: “Who have I been?” The question we must ask ourselves, as we begin the journey toward teshuvah, as we look in the mirror and change our ways, is: “Who can I still become?”
G’mar Chatimah Tovah.