Why Do We Give Tzedakah at Yizkor? 5787

Rabbi Dan Dorsch, Congregation Etz Chaim, Marietta, Georgia

In just a few minutes, we’re going to do something we do every year at Yizkor and no one notices it at all.

We’ll remember the people we’ve lost. We’ll say their names.  We’ll think about the people who shaped our lives and the gifts they gave us.

And then we’ll make a promise to give tzedakah.

It’s there in the text.  Clear as day.  We’re going to say the words on page 291: Hineni Nodev Tzedakah. “Here I am. I promise to give tzedakah.”

You know it’s remarkable. I’ve asked 10 people this week. Some have been saying Yizkor for decades.  And not one ever noticed that line; that during Yizkor every year we make that promise.

Which of course, has got me thinking about the meaning behind giving tzedakah on Yom Kippur.

Of all the things we could do in this moment of memory, why does Judaism ask us to make a promise to give tzedakah? Why not promise to keep Shabbat? Why not a promise to come to synagogue more often, to study, or to say more prayers? Why, when we remember someone we love, does Judaism ask us to transform our generosity into a gateway for memory?

I had been thinking about that question for a while when, this summer, I was having breakfast at Bagelicious with one of my former conversion students.  She is in her mid-twenties.

And then, like many people in their mid-twenties, she asked me a question that completely caught me off guard.

“Rabbi,” she said, “I know that when I was becoming Jewish we talked about a lot of stuff. But now that I am, how do I decide where to give tzedakah?”

I smiled. We talked about local needs. Jewish causes. I tried to work in the Kol Nidrei appeal. We talked about the values that guide Jewish giving.

But as I drove away, I couldn’t stop thinking about what she had asked.  How do I decide where I should give? Couldn’t she have just asked ChatGPT?  Or just have googled that? It was then that I realized I had probably missed the point of her question.

She wasn’t really asking me for a list of worthy causes. She was asking a much more important Jewish question: How do I take what I believe and turn it into how I live?

Obviously, we give because it helps someone else. But we also give because giving helps to shape us. The way we choose to give becomes part of the way we practice Judaism and helps define the kind of Jew we want to become.

And that made me realize that maybe the most important thing about tzedakah isn’t what happens to the money after we give it, but what happens to us after we do.

I once heard a colleague tell a story about giving tzedakah to someone who didn’t say thank you.

He saw someone on the street. He gave them a few coins. The person didn’t acknowledge him. And he was furious.

“How could this person not thank me?” he thought.  And then he realized something deeply Jewish.

He had it backwards.  The person who should be saying thank you was not the receiver, but the person who had the privilege of performing the mitzvah.

And this wasn’t just some modern rabbi’s nice idea. The rabbis wrestled with a similar question.

Roman official Turnus Rufus once challenged Rabbi Akiva in the Talmud: If God loves the poor, why doesn’t God simply take care of them? Why doesn’t God eliminate poverty altogether?  It’s a good theological question.

Rabbi Akiva’s answer was surprising. The person who needs something from us may actually be giving something to us. They give us the opportunity to fulfill a mitzvah: for us to learn to become more generous people.

Maimonides understood this same idea almost a thousand years later. His famous ladder of tzedakah, the one we learn in religious school, isn’t really a ranking of who writes the biggest check. It’s a ladder of how we give and, ultimately, of who we become through our giving.

At the bottom, we give reluctantly. At higher levels, we give without even knowing who we’re helping. And at the highest level, we help someone become self-sufficient without humiliating them.

Why is that the highest form?

Because for Maimonides, tzedakah isn’t simply about moving money from one person to another. It’s also about how we give and who we become in the process.

Generosity, when it’s done right, changes you.

I realized that no one had ever given my student a chapter called “How to Become a Generous Person.” And maybe that’s because you can’t learn that from a chapter. You learn it by practicing it.

No one could have handed her a list of worthy causes and said, “Here. This is how you become Jewish.” She was asking me because she understood something important: that becoming Jewish isn’t just about learning what Jews believe. It’s about figuring out how those beliefs become the way we live.

She’s just a good soul who assumed that going to the rabbi was the right way to figure it out.  (Even if she was wrong.  I’ll do better next time).

And maybe we haven’t done a very good job teaching that this is what tzedakah is: not simply a way to help other people, but a way to become the kind of person we want to be.

So many of us assume that tzedakah means “charity.”  That’s not wrong.  But it isn’t quite right either.  Tzedakah comes from the Hebrew word Tzedek: justice.  Justice is all about looking in the mirror and recognizing that we have obligations to other people.  That the person standing in front of us is also a part of us.  It’s noticing when Torah uses language like “Don’t harden your heart and shut your hand.”  That it says: Your heart.  Your hand.  Because Judaism understood a long time ago that the hardest part of generosity isn’t always giving something away.  Sometimes it’s allowing someone else’s need to actually reach in and touch you.

And that means giving isn’t just something we do for somebody else.  Giving is supposed to change the way you see yourself.

Throughout the year, we can ask: Did we help the family pay their rent?  Did we feed someone who was hungry?  Did we help a child go to camp?  Those things matter.  Of course they matter.

But on Yom Kippur, when we pledge to give tzedakah in memory of someone we loved at Yizkor, I want to posit that we’re being asked to consider another question too:  What is giving doing to me?

Is it making me more aware of other people’s needs?  Is it making me more generous?  Am I becoming the kind of person that my loved one would be proud of? Am I living by the values they lived by?

Why do we make a promise to give tzedakah in this moment of memory? Why is tzedakah the mitzvah we choose?  Because Jewish memory is never just about remembering someone. It is about remembering what they gave us and asking what we will do with it.   It’s about remembering we’re supposed to carry something forward.  Yizkor doesn’t simply ask us to recall a name.  It asks us to remember what that person meant to us.  What they taught us.  What they gave us.  And what they made possible.  And to promise ourselves that in a way, we’re going to carry them forward too.  Remembering someone isn’t only about holding onto the past.  It’s about deciding what part of that person is going to continue into the future.

What is the word that opens our Yizkor pledge?  It’s no coincidence that the word used is the word: Hineni.  “Here I am.”

Our President Lisa Olens spoke about it last night. Hineni is one of the holiest words in our tradition.  Abraham says it.  Moses says it.  Our shlichat tzibbur used it to begin the Musaf service today.

Hineni is the way we Jews answer a call larger than ourselves.

And during Yizkor, we will quietly say:  Hineni Nodev Tzedakah.  Here I am.  Here to give.

It won’t surprise you to find out that during Yizkor each year, I remember my own mother, Cheryl Nan Dorsch.

You’ve heard me speak about her before.  But what you may not know is that Cheryl devoted her life to children who had every reason to believe the world had forgotten them.  My mother was a social worker.  One of the most fulfilling parts of her job was working with children in crisis at summer camp.  That’s why our home in Philadelphia regularly hosted parlor meetings to raise money for a youth village in Israel for children at risk.

I remember those meetings.  People sitting around our home, talking about these children, talking about Israel, and talking about what we could do to help.

And it’s why every year at Yom Kippur, I give tzedakah to that same place.  Partly because I know how much it mattered to her.

But also, if I’m honest, because it asks me a question: Am I becoming the kind of person she hoped I would become?

And maybe that’s what promising to give tzedakah at Yizkor does.

It doesn’t simply preserve someone’s memory. It gives us a way to live out something we learned from them: their generosity, their values, their sense of responsibility.

My mother isn’t here for me to thank her. She’s not here for me to give anything back to her. But I can take something she gave me and give it to someone else.

So as we come to Yizkor today, I want to invite you to do the same. Think about that person in your life who had a cause they loved, a value they lived by, or a way of treating other people that helped shape who you are. And then, this year, don’t let that gift end with you. Make a pledge to give tzedakah in their memory. Not simply to honor what they gave you, but to carry something of theirs forward.

And in that moment, we’ll say something to them that we can no longer say to them in person:

Thank you.  I remember.  What you gave me will live on in me.