Yizkor/Sukkot VIII 5787 – A Shadow Cannot Exist Without Light

A Shadow Cannot Exist Without Light

Yizkor/Sukkot VIII 5787

Rabbi Jonathon Adler

 

We’ve spent the past week sitting in sukkot. Eating, chatting, learning. Many of those sukkot were beautifully decorated. Paper chains, banners, strands of festive lemon – i mean etrog – shaped lights. All kinds of art.

Our time in these sukkot gave us the perfect opportunity to sit under the sun and under the stars as they rise and set, as the moon moves across the sky. The light changed, along with the ways we perceived what we saw.

Mostly we were out there to remember the booths our ancestors dwelt in during the 40 years they spent wandering through the wilderness. Now, thousands of years later, our sukkot are intentionally built to be temporary. They must not stand up to the strongest winds. We do this to remind ourselves, as Kohelet says, that generations come and go, but the earth remains the same.

Just as generations always flow into the next, the sun always rises and always sets. As its light changes, our eyes observe our surroundings differently. Its luminous ebb and flow transforms how artists represent shapes and forms, but even more so, how they convey their vision of light itself.

The Israeli artist Yaakov Agam, who died this past June, used his art to demonstrate changing representations of illumination in the art he created. He understood that light could be fractured and fractalled. Things look different to us when we perceive things from different angles, like Agam’s art, which drastically reshapes itself depending on the viewer’s angle and on how each piece is lit.

After our service, go look at the three Agams hanging in our chapel. You’ll witness color, movement, light, shadow. The artist was very intentional in how he understood and represented these principles, and he noted that as the son of a rabbi, his work was always rooted in Jewish tradition. Inspired by the Lubavitcher Rebbe, he said:

Shadows are important. The shadow cannot exist without the light. Wherever there is shadow, problems or sorrow, there is light; there is hope. Sometimes we need the shadow to help us trace the source of light.

A perfect quote for Sukkot. Halakhah mandates that the schach block most of the sun’s rays, filling our sukkah with an interplay of light and darkness. The shadows our schach creates are an essential part of Sukkot, Z’man Simchateinu, the time of our joy.

Because even as we celebrate, we carry sadness. We remember that sadness and happiness are inextricably linked to each other. The spectrum of emotion between them enables us to understand, and even appreciate both even more. Hope and joy cannot exist without sorrow.

So too, shadow cannot exist without light, and light cannot exist without darkness. Tomorrow morning, when we start the Torah over at Bereshit, we’ll read about God separating light from darkness, but neither one could exist without the other. We require both light and darkness to be able to understand the distinction between them. And since we have them both, we know we’ll always have a balance. Between shadow and light. Between sorrow and hope. Between loss and joy.

The power of our joy at Z’man Simchateinu is why earlier this morning, we recited Hallel. We sang Psalms of praise and joy. One of the images in Psalm 114 is of the earth trembling at the presence of אלוה יעקוב, the God of Jacob, ההופכי הצור אגם מים, who turned rock into a pool of water.

Water, like schach, bends light. Just as the Psalmist sang of the pool of water which came from a rock, Yaakov Agam worked not only in colors, but in stone and water and fire. Some of  you have probably seen his most famous public work, the Fire and Water Fountain in Tel Aviv’s Dizengoff Square. Flames illuminate water, and that light changes as it passes through the water on the way to the viewer’s eye.

Another well-known work of his, which many of us have been privileged to see many times, is The World’s Largest Menorah, which is 36 feet tall and weighs about 2 tons. It’s installed annually at Grand Army Plaza in New York City. The lights and their massive scale manipulate the dark and create art.

Agam felt compelled to become an artist after watching wind change the shapes of sand dunes near Rishon LeTzion, where the artist grew up and where a museum of his work now stands.

“Reality changes all the time, and so does one’s outlook,” he said. Agam’s own art – and outlook – clearly changed over the course of his lifetime, as the world evolved around him, as he himself grew and aged, as the light shifted each day of his life.

Interplay, between sand and wind, between shadow and light, between reality and memory, matters to Agam’s art. One of his noteworthy works is “Desert and Bloom.” From one angle, it depicts simply sand dunes. But from another vantage point, verdant flora gleams green.

As we move around that gallery in the Agam Museum, our perception of the piece does, too. The contrast between a lush field and a barren dune, blown into its form by the wind, is enormous. But the dune has to exist before greenery blossoms there; the dune will endure after the grasses wither.

This duality impacts our perception of life and death. And as we remember Yaakov Agam, so too, we remember how his vision of light and shadow are represented in his art. Because light cannot exist without darkness. Sorrow cannot exist without hope. And life cannot exist without death.

Agam’s teaching seems particularly apt to say as we prepare for the Yizkor prayers today on Shemini Atzeret, at the end of Sukkot.

While Agam’s memory is one we can all hold collectively, at Yizkor, we remember in much more private, personal ways. We recall those who taught us the difference between elation and despair. We hold in our hearts the memories of those who brought color and light into our lives. Loved ones who came before us and brought us into our first Sukkot. We would not be who we are without them. Our own shadows cannot exist without their light.

Shabbat Shalom and Gut Yontiff.